Date Issue Released
Issue number
Safety issue title
Inadvertent activation of the elevator control system - pitch uncoupling mechanism
Safety Issue Description

Inadvertent application of opposing pitch control inputs by flight crew can activate the pitch uncoupling mechanism which, in certain high-energy situations, can result in catastrophic damage to the aircraft structure before crews are able to react.

Issue Owner
ATR
Transport Function
Aviation: Air transport
Date issue released
Issue Status
No longer relevant
Mode of Transport
Aviation
Issue number
Safety issue title
Alerting function of special weather reports (SPECI) is not met by the automatic broadcast services
Safety Issue Description

The automatic broadcast services did not have the capacity to recognise and actively disseminate special weather reports (SPECI) to pilots, thus not meeting the intent of the SPECI alerting function provided by controller-initiated flight information service.

Issue Owner
Airservices Australia in consultation with the Bureau of Meteorology
Transport Function
Aviation: Air transport
Date issue released
Issue Status
Closed – Adequately addressed
Mode of Transport
Aviation
Issue number
Safety issue title
Limited provision of flight information service for some non major airports
Safety Issue Description

For many non‑major airports in Australia, flight crews of arriving aircraft can access current weather information using an Automatic Weather Information Service via very high frequency radio, which has range limitations. Where this service is available, air traffic services will generally not alert pilots to significant deteriorations in current weather conditions at such airports, increasing the risk of pilots not being aware of the changes at an appropriate time to support their decision making.

Issue Owner
Airservices Australia in consultation with the Bureau of Meteorology
Transport Function
Aviation: Air transport
Date issue released
Issue Status
Closed – Adequately addressed
Mode of Transport
Aviation
Issue number
Safety issue title
Compromised separation recovery training
Safety Issue Description

Airservices Australia had not provided en route air traffic controllers with effective simulator-based refresher training in identifying and responding to compromised separation scenarios, at intervals appropriate to ensure that controllers maintained effective practical skills.

Issue Owner
Airservices Australia
Transport Function
Airspace
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Aviation
Issue number
Safety issue title
Air traffic control shift management practices
Safety Issue Description

The utilisation of  shift sharing practices for the Tops controllers resulted in them sustaining a higher workload over extended periods without a break, during a time of day known to reduce performance capability.

Issue Owner
Airservices Australia
Transport Function
Airspace
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Aviation
Issue number
Safety issue title
Identification of pitot probe in the trouble shooting manual
Safety Issue Description

The relevant tasks in the trouble shooting manual did not specifically identify the pitot probe as a potential source of airspeed indication failure.

Issue Owner
Airbus
Transport Function
Aviation: Air transport
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Aviation
Issue number
Safety issue title
Forecast terminology
Safety Issue Description

Fremantle Ports’ staff did not understand the significance of some wind and weather terminology used in the BoM forecast. Consequently, port procedures triggered by a BoM ‘gale’ or ‘severe weather’ warning such as preparing the tugs and calling the harbour master were not followed.

Issue Owner
Fremantle Port Authority (Fremantle Ports)
Transport Function
Marine: Shipboard operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine
Issue number
Safety issue title
Weather event management
Safety Issue Description

Fremantle Ports’ procedures for adverse weather were not adequate for weather that could reasonably be expected to occur. Some procedures could not be reasonably implemented and other were not monitored for compliance.

Issue Owner
Fremantle Port Authority (Fremantle Ports)
Transport Function
Marine: Shipboard operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine
Issue number
Safety issue title
Bureau of Meteorology weather warnings
Safety Issue Description

The Bureau of Meteorology (BoM) marine forecast title of ‘strong wind warning’ understated the ‘damaging winds’ expected during the ‘severe thunderstorm’. The forecast did not use recognised marine weather terms for wind speed, such as ‘gale force’.

Issue Owner
Bureau of Meteorology (BoM)
Transport Function
Marine: Shipboard operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine
Issue number
Safety issue title
Fremantle Ports’ risk assessment
Safety Issue Description

Fremantle Ports’ assessment of risks associated with a ship contacting the Fremantle Rail Bridge as a result of a breakaway, particularly from berths 11 and 12, was limited. Preventing a breakaway from berths where the wind was likely to be on a ship’s beam had not been considered. Similarly, the impediments to assisting a ship near Wongara Shoal after a breakaway had not been assessed.

Issue Owner
Fremantle Port Authority (Fremantle Ports)
Transport Function
Marine: Shipboard operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine
Issue number
Safety issue title
Train / platform clearances
Safety Issue Description

Due to the curvature of the track, a wide gap existed between the platform and train at the Heyington Railway Station. There are several stations on the Melbourne metropolitan rail network where wide gaps exist between platforms and trains due to track curvature. These gaps pose a risk to passengers.

Issue Owner
Metro Trains Melbourne
Transport Function
Rail: Passenger - metropolitan
Date issue released
Issue Status
Closed – Adequately addressed
Mode of Transport
Rail
Issue number
Safety issue title
Standards for train / platform clearances
Safety Issue Description

The existing standards stipulated minimum clearances between trains and platforms but did not consider the effect of the resulting gaps with respect to safe accessibility. 

Issue Owner
Metro Trains Melbourne
Transport Function
Rail: Passenger - metropolitan
Date issue released
Issue Status
Closed – Adequately addressed
Mode of Transport
Rail
Issue number
Safety issue title
Inadequacy of the doors open warning device
Safety Issue Description

The train door open/close indicator on the driver’s control console was inadequate as a warning device once the traction interlock had deactivated. 

Issue Owner
Metro Trains Melbourne
Transport Function
Rail: Passenger - metropolitan
Date issue released
Issue Status
No longer relevant
Mode of Transport
Rail
Issue number
Safety issue title
The train could be moved with the carriage doors open
Safety Issue Description

As designed, the traction interlock automatically deactivated after a period of time. This allowed traction to be applied and the train to depart with the carriage doors open.

Issue Owner
Metro Trains Melbourne
Transport Function
Rail: Passenger - metropolitan
Date issue released
Issue Status
Closed – Adequately addressed
Mode of Transport
Rail
Issue number
Safety issue title
Ship firefighting cache
Safety Issue Description

The large size and weight of the ship firefighting cache made it difficult for the duty Port Hedland volunteer firefighter to transport it to the wharf. 

Issue Owner
Department of Fire and Emergency Services (DFES)
Transport Function
Shore operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine
Issue number
Safety issue title
Professional firefighters in Port Hedland
Safety Issue Description

The limited professional firefighting capability in Port Hedland restricted the ability to launch an effective response to the fire on board Marigold. 

 

Issue Owner
Department of Fire and Emergency Services (DFES)
Transport Function
Shore operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine
Issue number
Safety issue title
Access control
Safety Issue Description

Suitable atmospheric testing equipment was not available in Port Hedland to ensure safe entry to fire-affected spaces on board Marigold. Access to these areas was not controlled until 53 hours after the fire.

 

Issue Owner
DFES
Transport Function
Shore operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine
Issue number
Safety issue title
Incident control
Safety Issue Description

The emergency response plans for a ship fire in Port Hedland did not clearly define transfer of control procedures for successive incident controllers from different organisations or contain standard checklists for their use. 

Issue Owner
BHP Billiton, Pilbara Ports Authority and Department of Fire and Emergency Services (DFES)
Transport Function
Shore operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine
Issue number
Safety issue title
International shore connection
Safety Issue Description

Port Hedland’s emergency response teams did not use the ship’s international shore fire connection. As a result, Marigold’s fire main was not pressurised with water from ashore.

Issue Owner
BHP Billiton and Department of Fire and Emergency Services (DFES)
Transport Function
Shore operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine
Issue number
Safety issue title
Halon system
Safety Issue Description

Marigold’s shipboard procedures for crew induction, familiarisation, fire drills and safety training were not effectively implemented. As a result, the ship’s senior officers were not sufficiently familiar with the Halon system’s operation. They did not identify its partial failure and did not activate the override function

Issue Owner
Korea Leading Company of Ship Management (KLCSM)
Transport Function
Marine: Shipboard operations
Date issue released
Mode of Transport
Marine