Investigation number
200404287
Occurrence date
Location
9 km ENE Sydney, Aero.
State
New South Wales
Report release date
Report status
Final
Investigation type
Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status
Completed
Aviation occurrence category
Loss of separation
Occurrence class
Incident
Highest injury level
None

Sequence of events

On 1 November 2004, a Boeing Company B767-336 (767) aircraft, registered VH-ZXC, was cleared for departure via the Sydney RWY 34R MARUB THREE standard instrument departure (SID) with a clearance limit of 5,000 ft. A military Lockheed Georgia Company C-130J (C130) aircraft was inbound to Richmond, NSW, from Nadi, Fiji, and had been cleared to descend to 6,000 ft and was tracking overhead Sydney for Richmond. As the aircraft approached each other about 5 NM east of Sydney, an infringement of the separation standard occurred.

The copilot of the 767 was the handling pilot for the sector and was manually flying the aircraft while tracking via the SID. After take-off, and when passing 1,500 ft, the copilot called for climb thrust to be set, and for the vertical navigation mode to be selected on the Mode Control Panel (MCP) of the aircraft's Autopilot Flight Director System. The pilot in command said that he selected climb thrust on the MCP, but did not recall seeing climb thrust annunciated. The copilot then called for the lateral navigation mode to be selected on the MCP and at 3,000 ft the aircraft began to reduce the rate of climb.

Passing through 4,000 ft, with the flaps fully retracted, the copilot noticed that climb thrust was not annunciated and advised the pilot in command that the Command Airspeed Bug was not in the correct position. The pilot in command reached over and reselected climb thrust and noted correct climb thrust annunciation. As the aircraft was passing through 4,600 ft and climbing at about 3,500 ft/min, the copilot engaged the autopilot. The pilot in command told the copilot to "nose it over" but the aircraft climbed to 5,350 ft before descending back to the assigned level of 5,000 ft.

The 767's traffic alert and collision avoidance system (TCAS) activated a resolution advisory (RA) for the crew to "monitor vertical speed". The pilot in command of the 767 saw the C130 during the period of the TCAS activation.

The crew of the C130 were alerted to the proximity of the 767 by the aircraft's TCAS display, when it was at 4 NM in the 10 o'clock position indicating 700 ft below their level of 6,000 ft. They then saw the 767 and their TCAS activated a RA advising them to climb, which they acted upon. At 6,400 ft, the TCAS RA instructed the crew of the C130 to maintain altitude. After the 767 was observed to pass below the C130, the crew said that they notified air traffic control of the infringement of separation standards. The air traffic controller then advised the crew to descend back to 6,000 ft because the aircraft were no longer in conflict.

Recorded radar data indicated that lateral separation between the aircraft reduced to 2.6 NM with a vertical separation of 600 ft. The required radar separation standard was 3 NM laterally or 1,000 ft vertically.

Aircraft Details
Manufacturer
The Boeing Company
Model
767
Registration
VH-ZXC
Serial number
24339
Operation type
Air Transport High Capacity
Sector
Jet
Departure point
Sydney, NSW
Departure time
1745 hours ESuT
Destination
Melbourne, VIC
Damage
Nil
Aircraft Details
Manufacturer
Lockheed Aircraft Corp
Model
C-130
Registration
A97J
Operation type
Military
Sector
Turboprop
Departure point
Nadi, Fiji
Departure time
1300 hours ESuT
Destination
Richmond, NSW
Damage
Nil