Investigation number
199400587
Occurrence date
State
Queensland
Report release date
Report status
Final
Investigation type
Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status
Completed
Aviation occurrence type
Loss of separation
Occurrence category
Incident

VH-UZP departed Townsville on the Townsville-Collinsville track but was then cleared to track direct to Mackay. VH-JJY, a faster aircraft, departed Townsville six minutes later and climbed initially on the Townsville-Bowen track before also being given a direct track to Mackay. The aircraft were thus on converging tracks. VH-JJY was subsequently cleared to divert up to 10 NM right of track to avoid thunderstorm cells. This brought the aircraft into potential conflict with VH-UZP, so the controller instituted a stepped climb procedure between the two aircraft. He then noted that VH-JJY was not diverting far off track so he cleared that aircraft to climb through the level of VH-UZP which by this time was level at FL210. The controller instructed VH-JJY to expedite climb to FL 220. However, VH-JJY then diverted further right of track (but still within 10 NM of track) and did not climb at the rate the controller expected. This resulted in a breakdown of separation standards between the aircraft. Recorded radar data indicated that when the aircraft were 3 NM apart, there was 200 ft vertical separation. The prescribed standard is 5 NM or 1,000 ft. Neither crew was given traffic information on the other aircraft. The controller, on realising that separation standards could be infringed, gave the leading aircraft (VH-UZP) a heading change from 125 degrees to 140 degrees. This was not of sufficient magnitude to ensure that the separation would be maintained. Significant Factors The following factors are considered relevant to the development of this incident: 1. Weather avoidance considerations resulted in the aircraft diverting off track. 2. Appropriate separation standards were not applied following the diversion of VH-JJY off track.

Aircraft Details
Manufacturer
British Aerospace PLC
Model
BAe 146-200-11
Registration
VH-JJY
Sector
Jet
Departure point
Townsville QLD
Destination
Brisbane QLD
Damage
Nil
Aircraft Details
Manufacturer
Fairchild Industries Inc
Model
SA227-AC
Registration
VH-UZP
Sector
Turboprop
Departure point
Townsville QLD
Destination
Rockhampton QLD
Damage
Nil