Investigation number
199702691
Occurrence date
Location
KATKI
State
International
Report release date
Report status
Final
Investigation type
Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status
Completed
Aviation occurrence category
Loss of separation
Occurrence class
Incident
Highest injury level
None

QFI6, a Boeing 747, had departed Bangkok for Melbourne and was tracking southbound on airway G463 at flight level (FL) 290. The aircraft was in contact with Bangkok Area Control Centre (BKK ACC) Sector 3 on 135.5 MHz. Sector 3 was a combined radar and procedural control sector. At 0212:54 QF16 reported passing ALGOR at FL290, estimating KABAS, the flight information region (FIR) boundary, at 0221. Just prior to reaching KABAS, the aircraft would pass the intersection of G463 and B219 at KATKI. These positions were all located beyond radar coverage, over international waters, within the procedural control portion of BKK ACC Sector 3 airspace.

A Korean registered Boeing 747, KAL362, had departed Kuala Lumpur for Seoul, tracking via B219 at FL270. Approaching KANTO, located to the west of KATKI, the aircraft was transferred to the BKK ACC. The crew of KAL362 contacted Bangkok Sector 3 on 135.5 MHz and reported passing KANTO at FL270, estimating KATKI at 0219, and requesting climb to FL290. The next reporting position was SINMA, to the east of KATKI. At 0217:20 Bangkok Sector 3 cleared KAL362 to climb to FL290. KAL362 reported leaving FL270 for FL290. At 0220:21 the pilot in command of QF16 advised the Sector 3 controller of having received a traffic alert and collision avoidance system (TCAS) traffic advisory (TA), and that the aircraft had been climbed to FL300 to avoid a collision with KAL362, but was now descending to FL290.

The crew of QF16 had received a TCAS TA, followed by a resolution advisory (RA) commanding a climb to avoid climbing traffic some 800 ft below. Each crew sighted the other aircraft. The KAL362 crew also received a TCAS TA, followed by a TCAS RA commanding a descent. The crew of KAL362 did not report a traffic confliction.

An investigation carried out by Aeronautical Radio of Thailand Ltd, the Thai air traffic control organisation, indicated that KAL362 was incorrectly given a clearance to climb to FL290 by the Bangkok Sector 3 controller, and that the crews of both QF16 and KAL362 were acting in accordance with the clearances issued to them. The minimum required distance between the aircraft was 1,000 ft vertical separation, or a lateral separation of not less than 15 minutes between their estimated times of arrival at KATKI, the intersection of their intended flight routes.

In accordance with ICAO Aircraft Accident and Incident Investigation Annex 13, paragraph 5.3, the circumstances of this occurrence provide for the State of Registry to institute and conduct any necessary investigation. After consultation with the Korean authorities it was agreed that BASI would take responsibility for the ongoing investigation.

Aircraft Details
Manufacturer
The Boeing Company
Model
747
Registration
VH-EBW
Serial number
23408
Operation type
Air Transport High Capacity
Sector
Jet
Departure point
Bangkok, THAILAND
Departure time
0058 hours UTC
Destination
Melbourne, VIC
Damage
Nil
Aircraft Details
Manufacturer
The Boeing Company
Model
747
Registration
HL-7476
Operation type
Air Transport High Capacity
Sector
Jet
Departure point
Kuala Lumpur, MALAYSIA
Departure time
0135 hours UTC
Destination
Seoul, Republic of Korea
Damage
Nil